Crisis Poverty And Development The Dominican Banking Crisis Economics Essay

Banks are the basis of an economic system, and it is really of import for the development of that economic system that Bankss are unafraid to guarantee economic growing. When these cardinal establishments are unstable and autumn to corruptness, the full economic system falls with them. The money that was deposited by the populace is lost, and compensation is non offered. Citizens have lost their nest eggs, measures can non be paid, and it becomes more hard for households to supply for their kids. Such a prostration of the banking system occurred in the Dominican Republic in 2003. The three major Bankss functioning the state, Baninter, Bancredito, and Banco Mercantil, collapsed due to fraud and weak regulative model. In March 2010, I went to the Dominican Republic with a group of pupils from my school to construct a house in an destitute community. The community, called Mahoma, had been ravaged by a hurricane six old ages ago, but the locals could non afford to mend or reconstruct their places. Over the class of six old ages, the organisation Dominican HOPE ( Health, Opportunity, Prosperity, and Education ) partnered with groups of high school pupils to reconstruct the houses that were destroyed in Mahoma. Local contractors were employed to oversee and assist the pupils with the edifice, and a cook was hired to fix repasts for the hebdomad. Monetary contributions were collected prior to departure to back up the school we stayed in, every bit good as vesture and toy contributions for the locals. All we did was construct one house and manus out a few hockey bags of contributions, but the grasp and echt felicity shown by the people of Mahoma towards us was incredible. This is because they genuinely have following to nil, and the fact that we even came to demo that we cared intend the universe to them. Sing how the people of Mahoma lived, and the poorness that they faced every twenty-four hours highly disquieted me, but their optimism and love of life inspired me. I want to make everything in my power to assist them, but I have come to recognize that alteration will hold to be implemented on a much higher degree than merely constructing a house in a hapless small town ; these people need strong economic reforms to provide to their specific demands, and less international intervention in their local economic system. The poorness seen today was caused by many old ages of irresponsible and illicit economic and fiscal personal businesss with other states, corporations, and establishments. I will be analysing the function of the International Monetary Fund ( IMF ) in developing states, specifically the Dominican Republic during its banking crisis in 2003. Such an establishment that was purportedly created to assist developing states, has non done much to better the economic conditions in the state, and the policies or plans that have been created by the IMF and implemented by the authorities have non catered to the specific demands and jobs being faced by the state and its economic system. Alternatively of supplying stairss towards a stronger economic system, the IMF and World Bank have capitalized on poorness, and provided the Global North with a steady income from this progressively impoverished state. Many Dominicans lost 1000000s of pesos worth of assets in fraud through analogue and seaward Bankss, every bit good as parallel accounting and the authorities relied upon the IMF to re-capitalize their Central Bank and prevent hereafter prostration.

Fraud and Corruption

Baninter, Bancredito, and Banco Mercantil were three of the largest Bankss in the Dominican Republic. In March of 2003, the governor of the Central Bank announced that Baninter had collapsed due to fraud and had acquired a debt of 55 million Dominican pesos. The authorities promised that the nest eggs of the people who had entrusted their money with Baninter would be compensated, but shortly thenceforth, Bancredito and Banco Mercantil besides collapsed due to fraud. The authorities repaid all of the depositors of Baninter, and harmonizing to Hanke ( 2004 ) “ the mean direct costs of those bailouts amounted to a reeling 15 to 20 per centum of GDP. ” Since these Bankss fell to fraud, the populace lost religion in their banking system. If people stopped lodging their money into Bankss, so the Bankss would be unable to do loans to consumers. If these consumers are unable to get a loan, so they will non be able to devour in the economic system, and that non merely leads to the consumers ‘ inability to supply for themselves and their households, but besides leads to the steady diminution of the economic system into a recession, or even a depression. The authorities would so hold to pass big sums of money on different signifiers of economic stimulation and occupation creative activity, non unlike the most recent planetary recession, in which Canada created their Economic Action Plan. The Canadian authorities has already spent over $ 60 billion on this stimulus bundle, which offers reduced personal income revenue enhancements, edifice substructure, and puting in research and development, to call a few undertakings. The Dominican authorities did non hold adequate money to reimburse the depositors enduring from the bank fraud, allow entirely to back up such a program, if such an economic crisis were to happen. The authorities sought the assistance of the IMF to re-capitalize their Central Bank, which involves the reconciliation of equity and debt and the accommodation of the construction of the establishment.

The International Monetary Fund

The IMF was created as a consequence of The Bretton Woods Conference in 1944. The conference was called as a answer to the debt crisis of the 1980s in which many developing states began defaulting on their international loans due to skyrocketing involvement rates and economic instability. These Bretton Woods Institutions were created in order to modulate debt refund and aid in development, every bit good as to impart money and promote international trade. The IMF consists of 187 member states who pay a rank fee, 25 % of which must be in difficult currency and 75 % in domestic currency. This fee is based approximately on the size of each state ‘s economic system, and is measured in Special Drawing Rights ( SDRs ) . The sum of SDRs a state has translates to the sum of voting power they hold within the IMF, every bit good as how much money they have entree to in a clip of crisis. The exact sums of SDRs allocated to each member state can be seen in the tabular array provided in Appendix 1. 100 % of the money that a state has invested in the IMF can be borrowed. The three chief activities of the IMF include supervising planetary development and reding member states, imparting money, specifically difficult currency, to back up policy plans, and offering proficient aid. The initial map of the IMF, as described by Taylor ( 2008 ) was, “ to supply fiscal resources to let states to work out the balance of payments crises without devaluating their currencies. ” Although this seems to be a critical establishment in the pursuit for development, there are many other facets of the IMF that farther perpetuate the instability of power seen between the Global North and the Global South. The finding of voting power as based on the size of a state ‘s economic system and fiscal part to the establishment is highly unjust ; it puts an unbelievable sum of power into the custodies of already powerful developed states, such as the United States, and prevents hapless states from holding a voice within the IMF. Another facet of the IMF ‘s maps is the status of structural accommodation policies, which member states who wish to borrow money must hold to follow in order to be loaned the money that they are entitled to. Member states borrowing from the IMF must foremost compose a missive of purpose explicating why the money is needed, and which policies they plan to ordain to guarantee that the money is being efficaciously, every bit good as guaranting that model is laid to forestall such a crisis from happening in the hereafter.

Structural Adjustment Policies

Structural accommodation policies require the authoritiess of the developing states to diminish their intercession in the local economic system, open their economic system to foreign trade, and prosecute export led growing, every bit good as puting a big focal point on debt refund. The conditions attached to the loans made these loans dependent on the successful execution of these policies, and if a state failed to implement them, they would non have blessing for a loan from the IMF. While these structural accommodation policies ensured a steady flow of capital to the international Bankss in the developed universe who had loaned money to developing states, they did and go on to make little in footings of promoting independent development of the state and its economic system. When a fragile, developing economic system opens itself to foreign trade, local concerns are put in competition with major international corporations, who non merely bring forth more but are besides able to sell their merchandises for less than the local concerns. Local concerns are critical to the development of an economic system ; they employ locals in all phases of productions, because they can non afford to outsource their production, which creates occupations in the economic system and provides citizens with a disposable income with which they can devour in that economic system. The money that is made by these concerns goes through a rhythm that stays in the state ‘s ain economic system, the money that is reinvested into the company as pay payments is used by workers in the local economic system, and the rhythm continues. When foreign concerns begin selling their cheaper merchandises in this economic system, consumers will necessarily buy these merchandises because they are able to devour more at a lower cost. Therefore, the local concerns who produce the same merchandises at a higher cost are forced to cut costs, lay off workers, and eventually, shut down their concern because they are non capable of viing with these new foreign concerns. If the local concerns shut down, so the local workers that were employed are left without a occupation, and are unable to devour in the economic system. They in bend seek to borrow money from the local Bankss, but if there is no religion in the local banking system, so there is non adequate money being deposited in the Bankss to prolong loans. The consequence is highly reduced ingestion in the economic system, increased poorness, decreased end product taking to decreased gross domestic merchandise ( GDP ) , every bit good as decreased revenue enhancement aggregation for the authorities. Merely opening a delicate developing economic system to foreign trade causes a concatenation reaction of negative effects whose effects can be felt through the full state. Similarly, export led growing discourages specialisation and variegation in trade, so if there are multiple developing states who are exporting the same merchandise but are selling at different monetary values, the states who are selling at the higher will sell less than those who sell at a lower monetary value. Those states do non hold any other exports to trust on for income, and once more it is highly hard for a developing economic system to vie in the international markets against economic world powers, such as the United States. Coercing developing authoritiess to go on paying off their debts and the involvement on those debts prevents the authorities from passing any excess money on societal plans, because that money is traveling to the refund of the loans. None of the conditions of these structural accommodation plans encourage the development of these states. In their missive of purpose, the Dominican authorities sought the aid of the IMF during their banking crisis in 2003, and requested “ a 24-month Stand-By Agreement from the Fund, in an sum equivalent to SDR 437.8 million. ” The missive outlines the policies that the authorities planned to ordain to beef up the banking system and the economic system, and specified that although the aforesaid policies were “ equal to accomplish plan aims ” , the authorities was “ prepared to take any farther steps that may go necessary for this intent. ” A full transcript of the missive can be seen in Appendix 2. This loan was approved by the IMF, and many visits to the capital to discourse the conditions ensued. Although there are non any public paperss depicting these treatments, it can be seen in other IMF studies on the province of the Dominican Republic that their presence has done really small in footings of cut downing debt and bettering economic stableness. A tabular array from this study can be found in Appendix 3.

Clinical Economicss

Alternatively of the neoliberal structural accommodation policies, Sachs ( 2005 ) proposes nearing economic jobs from a different positions. As opposed to using cooky cutter policies, he introduces the construct of clinical economic sciences, in which an economic expert evaluates specific “ symptoms ” of the economic system and makes a “ differential diagnosing ” of the economic system and prescribes economic policies that solve those specific jobs. Such patterns have been employed in Bolivia and Poland, where Sachs was hired by those authoritiess to work out their hyperinflation. Even though both economic systems were enduring from the same “ complaint ” there were many different facets of those economic systems that required really different methods of nearing a solution. A nexus to Sachs ‘ Table 1. Checklist for Making a Differential Diagnosis, can be seen in Appendix 4. Hanke ( 2004 ) proposes a similar option to the IMF ‘s structural accommodation policies. He suggests planing a plan that specifically caters to a state ‘s demands, and offers economic reforms that do non profit anyone but that peculiar state and its people.


The IMF is an establishment that is supposed to “ to supply fiscal resources to let states to work out the balance of payments crises without devaluating their currencies. ” Through the usage of neoliberal structural accommodation policies and devaluating domestic currency, the IMF merely succeeds in guaranting the refund of external loans to international Bankss. Economists should alternatively be sing all facets of the job and the local economic system in order to order an effectual and efficient solution. In the instance of the Dominican Republic, restructuring of the Central Bank and the full banking system is required, every bit good as diminishing rising prices and encouraging local concern. The Dominican Republic has come back from the banking crisis of 2003, but non without voluminous sums of debt accrued through the loans borrowed from the IMF. Debt decrease, non refund, is necessary to promote development and create a better economic balance between the Global North and South.