Increasing Electronic Waste In Indian Government Sector Environmental Sciences Essay

The automotive industry took a batch of rack in the seventiess for a sensed pattern called planned obsolescence. Detractors of the industry claimed that car manufacturers deliberately designed and built theoretical accounts that would corrode or endure critical mechanical dislocations after five or six old ages, therefore guaranting another sale within a few old ages.

Possibly merely a confederacy theoretician would impeach package shapers of borrowing this tactic from Detroit, but surely the changeless ascents of computing machine plans have helped bolster the gross of package companies. And to their recognition or disrepute, depending on one ‘s point of position — they sped up the obsolescence rhythm by presenting upgrades every two or three old ages. In many instances, upgraded hardware with extra memory was required along with the package

ABSTRACT – Today, there is a pressing demand for the Indian electronics industry to persistently track and unknot the complexnesss of the planetary supply concatenation, which is now being reshaped by a gamut of environmental conformity norms that have come into force. Without an actionable ‘India Strategy ‘ relying on a set of suitably benchmarked environment direction policies and execution programmes, the fight and growing of the electronics and information engineering ( IT ) industry are bound to be hamstrung. It is, hence, perfectly indispensable for companies to develop robust patterns to avoid high non-compliance costs. Action in the planetary market topographic point for cleaner engineering procedures and recycling programmes has already gathered important impulse.

This thesis makes an effort to re-discover the way of planned obsolescence ensuing in the coevals of e-waste in the Indian Government sector and the proposed actions towards control of growing of e-waste.

Cardinal Wordss: E-Waste ( Electronic Waste ) , BER ( Beyond Economical Repairs ) , MSW ( Municipal Solid Waste ) , DGS & A ; D RC ( Director General of Supply and Disposal Rate Contract, WEEE ( Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment ) , End Of Life, Survey.

I. Introduction

Recent statistics indicate that the entire one-year planetary volume of WEEE – besides referred to as e-waste – is shortly expected to make 40 million metric dozenss ( UNU, 2007 ) . In parallel, there is a dropping lifetime of electronic and electrical merchandises, high consumerism of these merchandises, low recycling rates and illegal transboundary motion from developed to developing states ( Puckett et al. , 2002 ; Brigden et al. , 2005 ; Deutsche Umwelthilfe, 2007 ; Cobbing, 2008 ) . The figure of electronic devices used per capita at the planetary graduated table will go on to

about 3,50,000 Tonss of e-waste yearly which is the figure that is available from the records that are documented. Besides, it is anticipated that approximately 5 lakhs dozenss ( plus ) of e-waste enters our state through the informal agencies under the pretense of charity/donations etc.

The starting point for coevals of e-waste in the Indian Government sector is the Government regulations themselves. Soon, India has no strict/stringent and tough rule/law sing transit, disposal and transboundary motion of e-waste, and in the deal many people have taken advantage of the same. The same is supported by the aureate trigon of e-waste hierarchy in Indian Government context which is depicted at Figure ‘A ‘ . The same is apparent signifier the fact upon tracking the life rhythm of e-waste from cradle to sculpt. This thesis for the interest of apprehension has considered the life rhythm of Personal computer as is envisaged below at a Government organisation right from the clip of its birth ( origin into service ) to its EOL [ 2 ] :

( a ) Central procurance of the Personal computer by the stores/warehousing section.

( B ) Upon populating its life until 05 old ages, the same is ‘surveyed ‘ and book maintaining of the same is done by ‘writing it ‘ off the Government leger. By this is meant that the Personal computer is foremost declared BER by a group of 03 forces, its HDD crushed utilizing petroleum and fundamental methods and the same disposed off as portion of MSW.

( degree Celsius ) E-Auction of this electronic waste is carried out to the registered sellers registered with the Government and the stock disposed away to the highest bidder. Extensive study at the Government offices at the southern provinces of India by the writer reveal that these bits are sold at a monetary value of Rs 80-100/Kg for CPUs, Rs 250 for proctors etc. However, the smaller devices such as keyboard, mouse, pressmans are taken for free. The highest bidder either resells it to a metal extractor or sentences the same by retrieving the valuable/rare metals and disposing off the remainder as portion of MSW.

When any EOL Personal computer is either a historical or an orphan waste, the same is stored in lofts and ne’er disposed off as so the disposal of the

ascent. For computing machine equipments, the first portion of the form is mostly in topographic point. Markets have mushroomed for re-usable equipment, french friess, power units and some other constituents. Unfortunately, much of what remains has traditionally been sent to the landfill.

Several considerations may be conveying about a alteration in what happens to computing machine equipment when it reaches the terminal of its utile life. Environmentalists are concerned about the disposal of computing machines in landfills. Similarly, disturbing inquiries refering environmentally safe and sound patterns overseas have been raised about the one time moneymaking export market [ 1 ] .


Ours is a state which invests really small in primary instruction and really small in primary wellness attention. Majority of people of our fatherland are non even cognizant of the injury that e-waste can do to us and many taking advantage of slack Torahs in our state and authorities ordinances make an easy vaulting horse out of it.

The term e-waste comprises of disused computing machines, nomadic phones and such other electronics that have reached their EOL and are of no stuff value to the original/end user. The terminal users therefore discard these as bit and these therefore find their manner as portion of MSW watercourse or in the lofts at places or workplaces due to the sentimental value attached with these electronics. It is to be borne in head that about 8-9 % of MSW in our state comprises of e-waste and this figure is invariably turning. We all are so permeant and dependent upon electronics that it has become the position symbol when we own electronic devices that have the latest characteristics. The rapid engineering alteration, low initial cost, high obsolescence rate have resulted in a fast growth job of discard of electronics around the Earth. Soon India generates

Numerous surveies have described assorted WEEE recycling techniques. These techniques include unfastened combustion printed circuit boards ( CBs ) and overseas telegrams ( Steiner, 2004 ; Brigden et al. , 2005 ; Gullett et al. , 2007 ; Wong et al. , 2007c ) , firing of CBs for component separation or for solder recovery ( Brigden et al. , 2005 ; Wong et al. , 2007c ) , toner sweeping, fictile splintering and thaw, firing wires to retrieve Cu, warming and acerb leaching of CBs ( Hicks et al. , 2005 ; Leung et al. , 2006 ) , gilded recovery from CBs with cyanide salt leaching or azotic acid and quicksilver merger ( Keller, 2006 ; Torre et al. , 2006 ; Rochat et al. , 2007 ) , and manual dismantlement of cathode beam tubings and unfastened combustion of plastics ( Puckett et al. , 2005 ; Jain and Sareen, 2006 ) . The three chief groups of substances released during recycling can be identified as therefore: ( I ) original substances, which are components of electrical and electronic equipment ; ( two ) subsidiary substances, used in recycling techniques ; and ( three ) byproducts, formed by the transmutation of primary components. These substances can be found within the undermentioned type of emanations or end products:

( a ) Leachates from dumping activities.

( B ) Particulate affair ( harsh and all right atoms ) from leveling activities.

( degree Celsius ) Fly and bottom ashes from firing activities.

( vitamin D ) Fumes from quicksilver amalgamate “ cookery ” , desoldering, and other combustion activities.

( vitamin E ) Effluent from leveling and tear uping installations.

( degree Fahrenheit ) Effluents from nitrile leaching, other leaching activities or quicksilver merger.

Dumped stuffs incorporating heavy metals and brominated and chlorinated fire retardents can impact dirts. The mobility of these substances towards other environmental compartments depends on diverse environmental parametric quantities such as pH, organic affair content, temperature, adsorption-desorption procedures, complexation, uptake by biology, debasement procedures, and the intrinsic chemical features of the substance

same becomes a incubus to the Government section as no record of the beginning of procurance or any other such records exists with the proprietor.

All the above therefore consequences in the coevals of e-waste and therefore the same has therefore resulted in the monolithic sum of e-waste generated by the Government sector. Appraisal of the right figure of e-waste generated in Government sector by the writer has proved futile in position of the fright of revelation by the authorities offices.


The discard of electronics in the Government sector follows a planned path wherein after the entry of electronics into its service life, it lives a utile pre-defined life and at its EOL it is sentenced by the user section / administration. With such planned obsolescence come a immense reserve of e-waste and the emanations from the recycling of this poses to be a great challenge for world. WEEE recycling in developing states is a daisy concatenation of procedures which are carried out in the informal economic system. Such informal economic systems can represent a considerable sum of the gross national merchandise ( GNP ) of developing or transitional states ( Schneider and Enste, 2003 ) . The activities of WEEE recycling in the informal sector are carried out by a scope of legal, unregistered and publically accepted concerns who give small concern to illegal and clandestinely executed procedures which have effects of great concern to the environment and human wellness.

The concerns collect, kind and manually separate electrical and electronic equipment. The procedures involve using petroleum methods to segregate substances or stuff of involvement from their original location within the electrical/electronic equipments. The same is supported by the figure picturing the phases of value of EEE which is shown at Figure ‘B ‘ .

for dioxin formation, Cu electrical wiring coated with Cl incorporating PVC plastic contributes to the formation of dioxins ( Kobylecki et al. , 2001 ; Gullett et al. , 1992 ) . Chlorinated and brominated dioxins and furans ( PCDD/Fs and PBDD/Fs ) , and assorted halogenated compounds like the polybrominated- chlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins ( PBCDDs ) and polybrominated-chlorinated dibenzofurans ( PBCDFs ) can be formed during WEEE combustion ( Soderstrom, 2003 ) . Once emitted into the ambiance, dioxins and furans are dispersed into the environment, and because of their semi-volatile and hydrophobic belongingss, they tend to roll up in organic rich media ( Adriaens et al. , 1995 ; Smith and Jones, 2000 ) . Higher brominated or chlorinated congeners degrade more easy and be given to partition more into lipoids ( Webster and Mackay, 2007 ) . They frequently deposit near the beginnings of emanation while the lower halogenated compounds are typically transported over longer distances. In the ambiance, dioxin and furans are capable to photodegradation and hydroxylation ( Watterson, 1999 ) .



Advent of new companies, changeless alteration in the monetary value construction, and leap in fabrication capacity, affect the profitableness & A ; borders of the companies drastically. Manufacturers have got to cast focal point on differentiation of the merchandises non merely in footings of packaging but besides sing expression & A ; engineering. This can stand the regular & A ; echt merchandises out from the generic & A ; cheapjack merchandises. Easy entree to internet information and presence of extended array of picks have made the consumers smarter, they want to have a quality merchandise at low rate, taking to the ferocious competition. The same has therefore led to assorted Government offices buying electronics of the coveted constellation at the lowest rate offered by the maker which is in awareness with the Government purchase policy. Besides an all out attempt is made in the way of supplying electronics with the best and latest constellation to all in the Government service.

( Sauve et al. , 2000 ; Georgopoulos et al. , 2001 ; Hu, 2002 ; Gouin and Harner, 2003 ; Qin et al. , 2004 ) . Ionic and on occasion, methylated heavy metals, are peculiarly nomadic and bioavailable ( Dopp et al. , 2004 ; Hirner, 2006 ) . Lower brominated congeners of fire retardents such as PBDEs are besides peculiarly mobile while higher brominated congeners tend to bond to atoms and exhibit lipotropic belongingss ( Gouin and Harner, 2003 ) . Heavy metals non recovered during WEEE intervention and residuary subsidiary substances like quicksilver and nitrile can leach through the dirt after disposal of wastewaters and signifier inorganic and organic composites within dirts. These wastewaters can besides come in H2O organic structures and the subsequent destiny of original and subsidiary substances will depend on the procedures described above every bit good as scavenging procedures ( between aqueous stage and deposits ) and volatilization [ Figure ‘A ‘ and ‘B ‘ ] .

Leveling activities besides release dust atoms loaded with heavy metals and fire retardents into the ambiance. These atoms either re-deposit ( wet or dry deposition ) near the emanation beginning or can be transported over long distances depending on their size. In add-on, dust straight incorporated in effluent can come in the dirt or H2O systems and together with compounds found in moisture and dry depositions, can leach into groundwater or react with the biology. The environmental destiny of atoms, ashes and exhausts incorporating heavy metals and PBDEs released by firing activities is similar to that of the emanations released by leveling activities. However, the thermal or unequal metallurgical intervention of WEEE can take to the formation of highly risky by-products such as polyhalogenated dioxins and furans. They are among the most risky anthropogenetic pollutants ( Allsopp et al. , 2001 ; Tohka and Lehto, 2005 ) and one of their most of import formation tracts is the combustion of plastic merchandises incorporating fire retardents and PVC ( USEPA, 1997 ) . As Cu ( Cu ) is a accelerator

functionality drops linearly with age. For illustration, the chance that a one-year-old merchandise is still functional is assumed to be 0.90 ; for a five-year-old merchandise it is 0.45.


It ‘s truly difficult to purchase a safe, lasting and easy to dispose and more so wholly coupled with this, an electronic loaded with the latest characteristics because they merely do n’t be. But the good side of this is that many computing machine and electronic companies are easy traveling in a better way. So far, the attempts have focused more on cut downing toxic chemicals in their merchandises than doing them longer permanent, but it ‘s a start. Post extended field work, the writer has chalked down a few of the methods to cover with planned obsolescence in the Indian Government sector:

( a ) Do n’t replace electronic appliances unless you truly necessitate to. A large per centum of the Personal computer ‘s and other electronic appliance that we toss out in the Government service are still working – so resist replacing and alternatively choose for reuse [ 10 ] .

( B ) Resist the impulse to upgrade unless your current device truly wo n’t work any longer. And, we as boies of this fatherland can assist the state in apparatus of ego propelled groups such as the Electronicss Take Back Coalition to assist force per unit area companies to do their merchandises safe and long lasting. And eventually, when you do flip out an electronic, be certain to give it to a Government authorized e-waste recycler so you know it wo n’t stop up poisoning person else.

( degree Celsius ) In position of all electronic merchandises purchased by the Government falling under the horizon of DGS & A ; D RC, the firms/manufacturers/OEM listed under DGS & A ; D RC need to be pressurized to follow the EPR by manner of firms/ makers taking back their electronic merchandises at their EOL. This will guarantee that the e-waste generated by the Government sector is contained and effectual stairss can be taken by the Government towards disposal of the same.

In doing merchandise retirement determinations in the Indian Government scenario, consumers consider many issues, including convenience and merchandise functionality [ 3,4 ] . As such, there is a high variableness in the timing of end-of-life determinations, which influences the age distribution and the quality of returned merchandises [ 3,4 ] . Since merchandise age and quality straight influence value of a merchandise on the resale market [ 5,6,7 ] , they are included in the theoretical account. Datas were collected about the retirement ages of the IT merchandises in assorted Indian Governmental offices [ 3,4 ] across the state. Age distributions were shown to be best characterized utilizing the gamma distribution whose form and graduated table parametric quantities can be altered to reflect differences in aggregation watercourse features. The gamma distribution herein can be best described to be of the signifier:

degree Fahrenheit ( x, thousand, O? ) = ten k-1 vitamin E -x/O? / ?? ( K )

O? K for x & gt ; 0 ; K, O? & gt ; 0

Here ten = random variable ( here, age ) , k = form parametric quantity, and I? = graduated table parametric quantity. Age distributions of retirement that occurs after a merchandise ‘s first service life were used to qualify terminal of rental retirements [ 3,8 ] . The agency of the distributions were shifted older to stand for plus recovery returns. Retirements that occur after a merchandise ‘s 2nd service life were used to qualify municipal pick-up retirements [ 9 ] . The agency of the distributions were shifted somewhat younger to stand for retail take-back returns. On a comparative graduated table, the distributional agencies ( in old ages of age ) of the aforesaid aggregation manners can be represented as:

AµEnd-of-Lease & lt ; AµAsset Recovery & lt ; AµRetail Take-back & lt ; AµMunicipal Pick-up.

No quantitative informations exist on the relationship between continued functionality of a merchandise and its age, but industry experts anecdotally correlate the two. Therefore, it was assumed that in the instance of Indian Government service that

( four ) Work in close affair with the GoI ( MoEF ) towards accomplishment of zero e-waste society.

( V ) Set a label of excellence i.e set high criterions and work towards accomplishment of the same.

( six ) Aim for the WEEE criterions to be amalgamated with the ISO 14001 criterions.

( B ) In position of bulk of our products/services being cyberspace enabled and since the common adult male in India wants himself to be associated with the IT age and considers it as the demand of the hr, we need to besides see the direction of e-waste in an cyberspace enabled mode. All electronic merchandises need to be tagged with RFID ( Radio Frequency Identification Device ) codification so that they are easy tracked from cradle to sculpt and the same will therefore guarantee that they are sentenced in an Electronic warfare-support measures at their EOL. The same can be therefore propelled by the set up of i-WEEE groups at all degrees right from the shred chooser to the Government through the generators of e-waste.

( degree Celsius ) The Government needs to flip in and bear 50 per cent of Capex for e-waste recycling installations on public private partnership ( PPP ) manner. Although, the same has taken form by the MoEF with support from Industry which needs to take a practical and matter-of-fact attack for effectual execution of the approaching e-waste policy, the same needs to be taken earnestly with the Government in checking down to a great extent on the informal e-waste participants [ 11 ] .

VII. Decision

India with the 2nd largest state in the universe being in footings of population and with the coevals of e-waste surmounting to impossible criterions and with dozenss and dozenss of e-waste pouring in every other twenty-four hours into our state, the demand of the hr is to undertake it in a tough, house and persevering mode.

Although there are studies that indicate that the victors at the 2010 Vancouver Winter Olympics

( vitamin D ) Resort to the purchase of green electronics which will guarantee that there is no environment debasement.

( vitamin E ) Ensure that there is no preset lifetime for electronics before they are sentenced to EOL.


From available informations, it can be seen that the Indian Government sector alongwith the private and public sector industries generate about 70 % of e-waste in this state. Since these three being the major participants in the coevals of e-waste in our state, the control of coevals of e-waste by these three major participants can guarantee that the e-waste generated is regulated.

The assorted attacks suggested by the writer towards control of e-waste but non limited to, include:

( a ) Include all the manufacturers of electronics which include the undermentioned, as portion of a route squad of e-waste participants by the creative activity of a Free society on Reduction of E-wastE ( FREE ) so as to curb/control the growing of e-waste. This society needs to include the undermentioned participants so as to accomplish a zero e-waste society:

( I ) Consumers

( two ) Traders, agents, retail merchants, logistics and intervention

Companies, re-use Centres and


Conformity strategies

National and sub-national



( seven ) Nongovernmental organization

Put a mission for the FREE society which should include:

( I ) Sharing of experiences and lessons learnt of direction of e-waste.

( two ) Develop newer and newer e-waste direction tools.

( three ) Set ambitious criterions.

[ 7 ] Kondoh, S. , et al. , Entire public presentation analysis of merchandise life rhythm sing the impairment and obsolescence of merchandise value. International Journal of Product Development, 2008. 6 ( 3 ) : p. 334-352.

[ 8 ] Guide Jr. , V.D.R. and L.N.v. Wassenhove, The Reverse Supply Chain, in Harvard Business Review. 2002.

[ 9 ] Management of Electronic Waste in the United States: Approach Two. 2007: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

[ 10 ] A. YOSHIDA, T. TasakiA. Terazono, , waste direction 29 ( 2009 ) :1602-1614.

[ 11 ] Dahmus, J.B. , et al. , Modeling the Economic and Environmental Performance of Recycling Systems. IEEE International Symposium on Electronics and the Environment. 2008.

[ 12 ] hypertext transfer protocol: // 10-vancouver-olympic-medals-made-from-e-waste_100325904.html # ixzz0zHP6Y7ld [ 13 ] hypertext transfer protocol: // ent/government-to-set-up-e-waste-treatment- facilities-ramesh_100337317.html # ixzz0zHPXLA14

[ 14 ] Beginning: Writer

Figure ‘A ‘

The Golden Triangle Of Waste Hierarchy In Indian Context

The Waste Hierarchy

would be decorating decorations that contain gold, Ag and Cu recovered from e-waste [ 12 ] . We besides need to deduce from this and take advantage of the presence of rare and valuable metals in e-waste and pull out lessons consequently. The Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs ( GoI ) has although cleared Rs.3.5 billion undertaking to clean up risky waste/municipal solid waste shit sites in Andhra Pradesh and West Bengal on pilot footing, much more demands to be done so as to undertake the turning threat of e-waste [ 13 ] .

At the grass root degree although assorted stairss are being taken by the Indian Government, the Indian Government besides needs to flip in by cut downing the coevals of e-waste. A first measure which the writer feels that can be taken is by cut downing the rule of planned obsolescence and in utilizing electronics beyond their pre defined life by following the 3R rule of cut down, reuse and recycle/repair of electronics till they cease to map, which could be foremost implemented in the Government services.

The writer will therefore sum it up be appealing to all that “ Arise, Awake and Stop Not Till The Goal is Reached ” in controling the growing of e-waste and condemning them in an ESM [ 14 ] .

VIII. Reference

[ 1 ] G.I.E. Media, Inc and Gale Group 2003.

[ 2 ]

[ 3 ] Environmentally Sound direction of e-waste, As approved vide MoEF missive No. 23-23/2007-HSMD dt. March 12, 2008

[ 4 ] hypertext transfer protocol: //

[ 5 ] Electronics Waste Management in the United States: Approach One, erectile dysfunction. O.o.S. Waste. 2008: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

[ 6 ] Guide Jr. , V.D.R. , R.H. Teunter, and L.N.V. Wassenhove, Matching Demand and Supply to Maximize Net incomes from Remanufacturing. Manufacturing & A ; Service Operations Management, 2003. 5 ( 4 ) : p. 303-316.

Landfill / Incineration without energy recovery





Figure ‘B ‘

Phases Of Value Of EEE

Fully A laptop with less voguish design characteristics


Functional, but A laptop that works, but is sulky with

With some drawbacks latest package

No longer functional, but A laptop with a defunct

Repairable harddisk


of EEE

A laptop that fell

In H2O

Not functional and non repairable