Worldwide, the quality of the environment is threatened by jobs such as planetary heating, H2O pollution, deforestation, and desertification ( World Commission on Environment and Development [ WCED ] , 1987 ) . Many of these jobs are direct or indirect effects of people ‘s mundane behaviors. Such behaviors are present at the both the person and the corporate degree, and are responsible for the threatening of the wellbeing of ecosystems worldwide ( Gore, 1993 ) . Because of this, the quality of the natural environment has become an issue of concern for both persons and states. Harmful environmental determinations and behaviors are really dearly-won at the person, societal and ecological degrees. Travel, ingestion, waste disposal, and the usage of energy are all behaviors that have possible impact on the environment and therefore necessitate to be changed in an environmentally friendly way.
In 1987, the WCED published their study, entitled, ‘Our Common Future ‘ ( WCED, 1987 ) better known as the ‘Brundtland Report ‘ , after its chair, Gro Harlem Brundtland. The study used the term ‘sustainable development ‘ widely and defined it as ‘Development that meets the demands of the present without compromising the ability of future coevalss to run into their ain demands ‘ ( p.43 ) . The study has enables the construct of sustainable development to be put steadfastly into the political sphere of international development thought ( Elliot, 2006 ) . In this study, Brundtland went on to reason that:
‘Sustainable development contains within it two cardinal constructs: the construct of ‘needs ‘ , in peculiar the indispensable demands of the universe ‘s hapless, to which precedence should be given ; and the thought of restrictions imposed by the province of engineering and societal administration on the environment ‘s ability to run into present and future demands ‘ . ( WCED, 1987, p.43 )
Sustainable development is a construct that has a planetary dimension and importance. It tries to guarantee the continuance of life in all of its diverseness and degrees, and supports changeless betterment in the quality of life for all worlds. Sustainable development is based on the values and rules of democracy, gender equality, solidarity, and regard for human cardinal rights ( Council of the EU, 2006 ) .
Even though our morality and interior values should state us that our development should non be at the disbursal of that of future coevalss, it is sometimes rather disputing to look far into the hereafter and predict the effects of our behavior today to those that will come after us. It is besides non easy to alter behavior, particularly when that behavior has become portion of us, has become ingrained in such a manner that we would happen it hard to work without it. A sustainable hereafter will necessitate cardinal alterations in people ‘s values, life styles, and in the manner society maps.
‘Achieving sustainability will depend finally on alterations in behavior and life styles, alterations which will necessitate to be motivated by a displacement in values and rooted in the cultural and moral principles upon which behavior is predicated. Without alteration of this sort, even the most enlightened statute law, the cleanest engineering, the most sophisticated research, will non win in maneuvering society towards the long-run end of sustainability. ‘ ( UNESCO, 1997 p.32 )
2.1.1 Climate Change
Climate alteration is go oning! This is apparent from addition in planetary temperatures, large-scale thaw of ice and snow and the rise of sea-levels ( IPCC, 2007 ) . It is no longer merely one of many environmental concerns, but it represents the most complicated and debatable environmental, societal and economic menace that the planet is confronting. It is the dominant environmental issue of our clip, and the greatest environmental challenge confronting policy-makers and the remainder of humanity. It is a turning crisis with many interrelated issues such as issues related to wellness, nutrient production, security and justness.
Climate alteration is a major preoccupation both for politicians and the general populace. Scientists lending to the IPCC ‘s 4th assessment study confirm that increases in the mean temperature of the Earth over the last old ages are mostly due to greenhouse gas emanations ensuing from human activities, in peculiar the combustion of fossil fuels and agribusiness ( IPCC, 2007 ) . An addition in the Earth ‘s mean temperature by more than 2 & A ; deg ; C above pre-industrial degrees could hold terrible effects for the environment, the economic system and human society itself ( IPCC, 2007 ) .
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change ( IPCC ) was set up by the UN in 1988. The IPCC is a scientific organic structure that works to supply strict and balanced, frequent studies reexamining and measuring current research and cognition about clime alteration and its consequence. IPCC produced its first assessment study in 1990, indicating at the anthropogenetic forcing to planetary heating, foretelling a uninterrupted addition in emanations and emphasizing that the effects of clime alteration will be felt largely in developing states ( IPCC, 1990 ) . Human activities that contribute to climate alteration include in peculiar the combustion of fossil fuels, agribusiness and deforestation. These cause an addition in the concentration of gases such as C dioxide and methane in the ambiance. Carbon dioxide and methane are the chief gases responsible for clime alteration, and are frequently termed nursery gases. The 1990 study was instrumental in the set up of the international pact for clime alteration, the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change ( UNFCCC ) . The purpose of the UNFCCC is to supply a model for intergovernmental policy doing to extenuate clime alteration and undertake the jobs that it poses. The convention was unfastened for signature at the Rio Earth Summit in 1992 and it entered into force in 1994. It now has 166 signatures.
In 1997, at the Conference of the Parties III ( COP-3 ) , in Kyoto, Japan, developed states agreed to cutting their nursery gas emanations to 5.2 % below 1990 degrees between the old ages 2008 and 2012 ( Shah, 2002 ) . A binding understanding and general model known as the Kyoto Protocol was defined for this overall decrease. The Kyoto Protocol is linked to and an add-on to the UNFCC, which entered into force in 2005.
The term of the protocol will shortly stop and so far, rich, developed states have decidedly non committed themselves to it, with nursery gas emanations non been meaningfully reduced. The grounds given are normally economic 1s. Another pact is now being negotiated – a pact that aims to set more force per unit area on developing states like India to hold and adhere themselves to emanations marks ( Shah, 2009 ) . It is clear that to cut down the negative impacts of clime alteration, planetary nursery gas emanations must be reduced significantly, but how and by whom? Should developing states that are merely now increasing their emanations be treated in the same manner as the rich states that have historically contributed the most to these emanations?
The European Union Sustainable Development Strategy ( EU SDS ) ( Council of the EU, 2006 ) is a scheme that will enable the EU to carry through its committedness towards sustainable development. The chief organic structure of the Strategy is built around seven cardinal challenges. Climate alteration and clean energy is the first amongst these seven key challenges.
IPCC ‘s Fourth Assessment Report ( 2007 ) , based on consistent grounds that was non available in the 3rd assessment study, confirmed that human activities were responsible for the addition in nursery gas concentrations in the ambiance, with anthropogenetic coercing detected in all continents except Antartica. The study made clear that current attempts at extenuation are non plenty to halt the addition in nursery gas emanations over the following decennaries ( IPCC, 2007 ) . The study besides warned that the jutting addition nursery gas emanations and in planetary temperatures will hold serious effects for life on Earth – effects that are much larger than those observed in the twentieth century ( IPCC, 2007 ) . Global heating will take to more upwind appendages and catastrophes and every bit good as drouth or implosion therapy in some countries, species extinction, loss of agricultural productiveness, more unwellnesss and a rise in sea degrees which will jeopardize coastal countries and little islands, like Malta.
In 2009, two old ages from the termination of the Kyoto protocol, policy-makers from around the Earth met in Copenhagen for the COP-15, to find and make up one’s mind how to undertake this planetary menace in the coming old ages. 2009 had to be the twelvemonth in which dialogues end and a new protocol ( the Copenhagen Protocol ) agreed upon. This conference was preceded by a batch of hope and optimism that an understanding for a merely and meaningful protocol would be reached. The assemblage of caputs of provinces and curates from over 190 states attracted a batch of public attending and the ballyhoo increased as the dialogues were pulling nigh. But the meeting failed to come up with such a protocol, alternatively coming up with a papers called the Copenhagen Accord which does non perpetrate states to existent binding marks. Without a merely, ambitious and binding understanding, the negative effects of clime alteration and unfairness continue to augment, with the universe ‘s poorest people enduring the most. So the battle to set force per unit area on political leaders to halt conveying up alibis and present more during such dialogues continues.
Not everyone though agrees with such international dialogues to seek and extenuate clime alteration. Disagreement is based on the thought that there is deficiency of consensus amongst climatologists that clime alteration is happening and that it is human induced ( de Freitas, 1994 ) . Gerhard ( 2004 ) , for illustration, argues that since clime alteration is a natural phenomenon, worlds have no control over it and therefore dialogues to extenuate clime alteration are a waste of valuable clip and resources. Our focal point should therefore be on version to climate alteration. Many surveies show grounds that clime alteration theoretical accounts used by IPCC are weak and hyperbolic and that clime alteration is non due to anthropogenetic addition of nursery gases ( Balling, 2000 ; Gerhard, 2004 ; Kauffmann, 2007 ; Khilyuk and Chilingar, 2004 ; Khilyuk, 2003 ; Kininmonth, 2010 ; Priem, 2007 ) . Many surveies mention an addition in solar activity as the major subscriber to planetary heating ( Balling, 2000 ; Priem 2007 ; Khilyuk, 2003 ) whereas others mention factors such as emanations from oceans ( Kauffman, 2007 ) and gas migration and natural beginnings of C dioxide and methane ( Khilyuk and Chilingar, 2004 ) . Gerlich and Tscheuschner ( 2009 ) travel a measure further and province that there are no common physical Torahs between the manner that warming goes on in nurseries and what they call fabricated atmospheric nursery consequence. Contrasting many other surveies, Chilingar et Al. ( 2008 ) usage calculations to demo that addition in atmospheric C dioxide consequence in atmospheric chilling instead than warming. Idso ( 1991 ) besides argues that an addition in atmospheric C dioxide should be welcomed as the solution to the rejuvenation of the Earth.
2.1.2 The Climate Change Issue in Malta
As a little island province in the center of the Mediterranean basin, Malta is one of the most vulnerable states to the effects of clime alteration. Major concerns are the rise of sea degrees and the salinisation of the H2O tabular array. Climate alteration is besides impacting of import sectors such as touristry and agribusiness. In 1988, it was Malta that raised consciousness at the UN General Assembly of clime alteration as an of import sustainability issue, declaring clime as a heritage to be passed on to future coevalss ( United Nations, 1988 ) . This consciousness initiated a series of events that finally led to the set up of the UNFCC and the Kyoto Protocol.
Despite our of import function in originating planetary treatments and understandings, locally we are still far behind in following effectual emanation decrease measures ourselves. Harmonizing to the National Greenhouse Gas Emissions Inventory Report ( Malta Environment and Planning Authority, 2009 ) , the gross national nursery gas emanations have been increasing twelvemonth on twelvemonth, making 3,034 Gg in CO2 equivalents in 2007. The energy sector including conveyance was identified as the largest subscriber ( 88 % of the entire emanations ) . This is no surprise when one considers that our energy is all fossil-fuel based.
In October 2008, the Hon. Leo Brincat, chief Opposition Spokesperson for the Environment, Sustainable Development and Climate Change, proposed a clime alteration gesture in the House of Representatives. He proposed a jurisprudence that provides a program of action to make decrease marks and enforcement of the decrease steps needed. The gesture was non supported by the authorities though. Alternatively, a clime alteration commission was set up in 2008 to turn to the demand of a national scheme for decrease in nursery gas emanations. The Climate Change Committee presented its concluding study ‘National Strategy for Policy and Abatement Measures associating to the Reduction of Greenhouse Gas Emissions ‘ in May 2009 after a procedure of audiences, and set frontward assorted recommendations. FoE Malta criticised this study since it failed to urge a legal model to implement the extenuation measures that are much needed. Besides NGOs were non represented in the clime alteration commission. A new clime alteration commission has now been set up to outline an version to climate alteration scheme study.
As a non-Annex I state, Malta had no emanation decrease committednesss within the Kyoto Protocol, but was required to describe to the UNFCC sporadically. Malta presented its first communicating in 2004. Malta though is besides an EU member and as such has to stay by the Emissions Trading Directive. At COP-15, Malta proposed its inclusion amongst the Annex 1 states within the Kyoto protocol. This was accepted by the Conference, intending that now as a state we have much more duty to demo commitment towards the protocol. Surprisingly plenty, after such a declaration of willingness of duty towards decrease steps, Malta insisted that the EU should merely perpetrate to 20 % emanation cuts below 1990 degrees instead than the 30 % that the EU was taking for.
2.2 The Role of Education
Education is the chief reply for conveying about the alterations required in the cognition, values, and behaviors, to get down working towards sustainable development. Numerous international statements have pointed to the cardinal function of instruction as a alteration agent, from making ‘new forms of behavior of persons, groups and society as a whole towards the environment ‘ ( UNESCO, 1978 ) , to being ‘critical for advancing sustainable development and bettering the capacity of people to turn to environment and development issues ‘ ( United Nations Conference on Environment and Development [ UNCED ] , 1992 ) . Hence it is really of import to reorient educational systems and course of study towards this function. Education at all degrees and in all its signifiers represents the starting point for turn toing planetary issues such as, poorness, HIV/AIDS, the environment, and alterations in production and ingestion forms. Education is the most equal agencies to guarantee that everyone sees the relevance of behavioral alteration, is knowing about the alterations that are needed and sufficiently skilled and motivated to be an militant for alteration.
EE as an instruction motion started in the sixtiess in response to scientists ‘ concerns about environmental debasement ( Gough, 2002 ) . Rachel Carson was one of these scientists and she is frequently mentioned as a innovator in the publicity of environmental consciousness through the publication of her book, Silent Spring ( 1962 ) . EE aims to propagate the values, attitudes, determination devising accomplishments and actions needed to forestall environmental debasement and promote sustainable development ( Tuncer et al. , 2005 ) .
Electrical engineering gained international acknowledgment in 1972, when the UN Conference on the Human Environment held in Stockholm, Sweden, declared EE as a critical tool in turn toing planetary environmental issues. EE has been recognised as possessing the capableness of increasing responsible behavior by persons, endeavors and communities, through advancing consciousness and cognition on assorted environmental issues ( United Nations, 1972, Principle 19 ) .
Equally far as contents are concerned, EE goes beyond the protection of nature and the environment and covers both the natural environment and societal 1. Harmonizing to Magnus et Al. ( 1997 ) the chief end of EE is to eventually make pro-environmental behavior. What type of pro-environmental behaviors are we taking at though? Is it behaviour on an single degree so as non to do deterioration of environmental jobs, or behaviour that attempts to work out these issues, possibly even on a social degree? EE is ‘aimed at bring forthing citizens that are knowing about the environment and its associated issues, aware of how to assist work out these jobs, and motivated to work toward their solution ‘ ( Stapp et al. , 1969 ) . EE aims to promote enviornmentally literate citizens to play an active function in environmental issues. This can be done through prosecuting in pro-environmental behavior and actions such as seting force per unit area on environmental policy-makers. EE, decently understood should amount to a wide-ranging womb-to-tomb instruction. It should fix the person for an ethical life by easing apprehension of the major jobs of the modern universe, and by supplying the accomplishments, values and properties needed to play a productive function towards bettering life and protecting the environment ( UNESCO, 1977 ) .
Agenda 21 ( UNCED, 1992 ) is a thorough program of action to be adopted globally, nationally and locally by administrations of the UN, authoritiess, and administrations everyplace. The full text of Agenda 21 was revealed at the UNCED ( Earth Summit ) , held in Rio de Janeiro in June 1992, where 178 authoritiess voted to follow the programme. In Agenda 21, high precedence is given to the function of instruction in prosecuting development that is sustainable – development that protects nature whilst bettering the human quality of life. The Agenda focuses on the demand to further the values and attitudes that lead to pro-environmental behavior and envisages the procedure of re-orienting instruction towards that need. Chapter 36 focal points on the importance of all types of instruction in accomplishing sustainable development. The chapter identifies three major driving forces to get down the work of environmental and development instruction: improving basic instruction ; reorienting bing instruction towards the construct of sustainable development, and developing public apprehension, and consciousness. ( UNCED, 1992 )
Yet, by 1997, the UNESCO international EE conference in Thessaloniki, was reflecting on why the universe ‘s instruction communities had non responded to all of the statements, declarations and authorizations. As Federico Mayor, UNESCO ‘s so Director-General commented, ‘Who would deny that excessively small has been achieved? ‘ ( 1997 ) . Besides a study to the Commission on Sustainable Development indicates that the major work was still to be done ( UNESCO Secretary General, 2000 ) .
The vision of sustainable development opened up to include the rules of societal justness and the battle against poorness ( UK National Commission for UNESCO, 2005 ) , meaning the importance of solidarity, justness and partnership in sustainable development. Education towards this vision was termed Education for Sustainable Development ( ESD ) . ESD promotes sustainable life style by fiting scholars with the right cognition, values, attitudes and accomplishments ( UNESCO, 2002 ) . The Johannesburg Summit in 2002 proposed the Decade of Education for Sustainable Development ( DESD ) to bespeak that instruction and larning are of extreme importance in any attempted attacks towards sustainable life styles and development. Later, UNESCO declared the decennary crossing January 2005 to December 2014 to be the UN DESD ( Combes, 2005 ) . This determination was taken with the overall ends of:
supplying everyone with the chance to profit from instruction
incorporating the values of sustainable development into all facets of larning
promoting alterations in values, attitudes, behavior and life styles that are needed for a more sustainable and merely society for all
( UNESCO, 2006 )
The Framework for the UN DESD International Implementation Scheme ( UNESCO, 2006 ) , establishes ESD as instruction that addresses all three facets of sustainable development – society, environment and economic system. This position of ESD purposes to widen people ‘s positions enabling them to measure the effects of their actions in a more complex and holistic mode. Harmonizing to McKeown and Hopkins ( 2005 ) , even though ESD has its ain set of ends, EE and ESD portion the common aim of promoting alterations in behavior, toward more sustainable life styles. ESD and EE should besides fit citizens with the accomplishments to confront present and future environmental jobs. Responsible decision-makers who will move in favor of sustainable development must besides be the consequence of such instruction.
The 4th international EE conference, ‘Environmental Education towards a Sustainable Future-Partners for the Decade of Education for Sustainable Development ‘ held in Ahmedabad in 2007, sought to understand how EE developed since the first of such conferences in Tbilisi. The relationship between EE and ESD was explored and the design for advancement through the DESD was set ( UNESCO, 2007a ) .
The United Nations DESD International Draft Implementation Scheme ( UNESCO, 2005 ) identifies climate alteration as a present major environmental issue and therefore as an issue that can be should be really much targeted by ESD. Besides, at the 2007 High-Level Planning meeting, it was acknowledged that clime alteration is a pressing planetary issue that needs to be portion of ESD ( UNESCO, 2007b ) . Using climate alteration as a context in ESD, contributes to constructing the accomplishments and attitudes needed to alter our values and behaviour towards more sustainable life styles.
2.2.1 Environmental Education in Malta
Harmonizing to Pace ( 1995, as cited in Pace, 1997 ) , the patterned advance of EE in Malta followed three phases:
The Awareness Stage ( 1960s – 1970s ) – characterised by sporadic activities aimed at educating and raising public consciousness on the province of the local environment and the demand to make something. These activities helped to get down determining public sentiment, to increase consciousness and concern, and to foreground the demand for a supportive substructure for future EE enterprises.
The Fragmentary Stage ( 1980s – early 1990s ) – characterised by the institutionalisation of EE. Various uncoordinated enterprises towards EE created a batch of struggles and small important advancement.
The Coordinated Phase ( mid-1990s ) – chiefly affecting a finding to put up a National EE Strategy and characterised by a countrywide will to organize activities and to utilize the available resources every bit sagely as possible.